The short answer
A denial letter says your mortgage company won’t offer a loan modification, at least for now. It must tell you the specific reason. Often you can appeal, and you may still qualify for other help.
If your complete application arrived at least 90 days before any foreclosure sale, you usually have 14 days to appeal, and someone different must review it. Read the letter today, because the clock is already running.
The letter, decoded
It may be called a notice of decision, a denial notice or a letter saying they are unable to offer you a modification.
SAMPLE MORTGAGE SERVICING
NOTICE OF DECISION ON YOUR REQUEST FOR ASSISTANCE
1We reviewed your complete application. We are unable to offer you a loan modification for the following reason:
2Your income is not enough to support a modified payment.
3You may appeal this decision. Your written appeal must be received within 14 days of the date of this letter.
4Other options you may qualify for: short sale; deed in lieu of foreclosure.
- 1The decision. Which option they turned down. Check whether every option was reviewed, not just one.
- 2The reason. It must be specific. Common reasons are income too low or too high, missing papers, or the loan owner’s rules. Check whether it’s true.
- 3Your right to appeal. How long you have and where to send it. Mark the deadline today.
- 4Other options. What else you may still qualify for, like a repayment plan or a short sale.
What usually happens next
- TodayRead the reason and mark the appeal deadline.
- Within 14 daysSend your written appeal, with proof of anything they got wrong.
- Within 30 days of itThey must tell you the result of your appeal in writing.
- ThenIf it works, you get an offer. If not, ask about every other option.
What to do this week
- Check the reason against your numbers. Was your income, expenses or household size wrong? Did they use an old pay stub?
- Write a short appeal saying what was wrong and why, and attach proof. Stick to the facts.
- Send it the way the letter says, and keep proof of the date it arrived.
- Get free help from a HUD-approved housing counselor. They read these letters every day.
If the appeal doesn’t work
Apply again later
If your income or situation changes, you can usually send a new application.
Catch up or pause
Ask about a repayment plan or forbearance, even if a modification didn’t work.
Ask who owns the loan
Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, FHA, VA and USDA loans each have their own options.
Sell on your terms
A sale or short sale can settle the debt and avoid a foreclosure.
Deed in lieu
You give the home back, and the debt is often settled. Get advice before you agree.
Talk to a lawyer
Especially if you have a sale date, or think your mortgage company broke the rules.
Common questions
Can I appeal every denial?
Not always. Federal rules give you an appeal when a loan modification is denied and your complete application arrived 90 days or more before a foreclosure sale. Your letter should say whether you can appeal and by when. If it doesn’t, ask in writing.
Does the foreclosure stop while I appeal?
On most home loans, if your complete application arrived more than 37 days before a sale, your mortgage company can’t hold the sale until your appeal is decided. Ask them to confirm it in writing.
What if the reason is wrong?
Say exactly what is wrong in your appeal and attach proof. You can also send a written notice of error. They must look into it and answer you in writing.
Do I need a lawyer?
Not to appeal. Talk to a lawyer if you have a sale date or court papers, or if you think your mortgage company broke the rules. Find free legal help at LawHelp.org, or call HUD’s counseling line at 800-569-4287.
Can I apply again later?
Usually yes, especially if something changes, like your income. But a second application may not get all the same protections as the first, so ask a counselor about timing.
Sources
- 12 CFR 1024.41: loss mitigation, including denial reasons, appeals and the 37-day rule (Regulation X)
- 12 CFR 1024.35: notices of error (Regulation X)
- If I can’t pay my mortgage, what options do I have? (Consumer Financial Protection Bureau)
This guide explains general rules, not your own case. Written from official sources and checked by a HUD-certified counselor. If something here is out of date, tell us at help@clifhousing.com.